If you like it spicy, try the horseradish based Eli's Hot Mustard with your meat and cheese. If it is a savory sweet flavor you crave, try Emma's Sweet Mustard. Either way, your Amish mustard experience will bring you and your guest back for more. Enjoy! These are recipes handed down from generation to generation in the Amish communities. The highest quality ingredients are used to make these the best mustards on the market for your taste buds to enjoy!

              Talk about HEAT! We like it with bologna, meats and even on our sandwiches! There's not much you can't put this on or mix it with. Although we've never tried it, we cannot see mixing it with one of our jams... not a good idea, but anything else!

$4.79
12 oz

              Mother always has some of this, ALWAYS! The traditional yet "no so traditional" sweet mustard - great on burgers, sandwiches, cheese, pretzels and just about everything else you could consider putting mustard on. Just a bit o' spice and sweet, perfect for dipping!

$4.79
12 oz